November Birthstone
Share
The November birthstone is actually a pair. Topaz is the traditional choice, and citrine was added to the November list in 1952. Both come in warm golden shades, which is why people mix them up, but they’re different minerals with different prices and care needs. This guide covers how to tell them apart and how to pick one, especially if you’re looking at gemstone rings for everyday wear.
What is the November birthstone?
Topaz comes in a wide spread of colours, with golden, blue, pink and colourless stones all common in jewellery. Citrine is the transparent yellow to brownish-orange form of quartz, and the two stones have a long history of being mistaken for each other.
Pakistan has its own claim to topaz. Fine pink topaz is mined at Ghundao Hill near Katlang, although it turns up rarely even there.
Topaz and citrine meaning
In traditional lore, topaz stands for friendship and strength, while citrine is linked to prosperity and clear thinking. Some old beliefs also held that citrine could calm a hot temper. None of this has scientific backing, so think of it as part of the gift’s story and nothing more.
Topaz vs citrine at a glance
|
Topaz |
Citrine |
|
|
Mineral |
Topaz |
Quartz |
|
Hardness (Mohs) |
8 |
7 |
|
Weak point |
Can split along one plane if knocked |
Can crack with sudden temperature change |
|
Usual treatment |
Blue is irradiated and heated; some is coated |
Most is heated amethyst |
|
Price |
Blue is inexpensive; strong golden or pink costs far more |
Affordable in most sizes |
|
Cleaning |
Warm soapy water only |
Warm soapy water |
Hardness numbers can mislead. Topaz resists scratches better than citrine, but GIA rates its toughness as poor because of its cleavage, so a sharp knock can split it. Citrine holds up fairly well, though an abrupt temperature change can fracture it. Natural citrine is rare, so most stones on sale started as pale amethyst and were heated to turn yellow.
How to choose between them
For a November birthstone ring you’ll wear every day, the setting matters more than the stone. Jewellers tend to put valuable topaz in protective mountings, or use it in pieces that take fewer knocks, such as pendants and pins. A bezel setting that wraps the edge of the stone is a sensible choice for either gem on a ring.
Budget is the other factor that matters. Despite being relatively inexpensive, blue topaz tends to get slightly pricier by the carat as it grows in size, so it's an easy choice when it comes to a big stone. Topaz is not officially standardized, and it is the colour that determines its value, so assess its colour rather than what is written on the tag.
Custom birthstone jewellery allows you to make a decision on what shade of birthstone you want to look for, or even a stone that matches your existing design.
Common buying mistakes
- Treating “smoky topaz” or “topaz quartz” as real topaz. Brown quartz is sometimes sold under these names, and it’s a different, cheaper stone.
- Assuming citrine is untreated. Ask the seller directly. A trustworthy one will tell you if it’s been heated.
- Using harsh cleaners on mystic topaz. Its colour comes from a thin coating that abrasive cleaners or polishing wheels can remove.
Caring for November birthstone jewellery
- Clean either stone using warm water and a soft brush with a mild soap.
- Topaz is incompatible with using steam cleaners or ultrasonic machines.
- Keep golden or brown topaz away from excessive heat and sun as it tends to fade.
- Remove rings before gardening or the gym.
Picking your November birthstone
If you prefer blue or pink, or a more brilliant, golden stone, go with a topaz and have the edges protected. If you prefer warm yellow and orange and you're in need of a larger stone on a budget, choose citrine. Always inquire about the stone's treatment before purchasing, and plan to clean it yourself.